The European Court of Human Rights (the ‘ECtHR’ or ‘the Court’) has excessive jurisprudence on prison conditions, especially regarding the minimum personal space of inmates. The case law culminated in the recent judgement of Muršić, which was decided last October by the Grand Chamber. In this decision the Court addressed the inconsistencies in its jurisprudence regarding the minimum acceptable space. In the Muršić decision the Court ruled that if the personal space goes below 3 square meters, there is a strong presumption of a violation of Article 3 and the judgement resolves important other contradictions also. It was not totally consistent in the recent practice of the Court whether the decisive space is 3 or 4 m2 or that the personal space below this amount is in itself a violation or not. The origin of the 3 m2 threshold was also not clear from the case law of the Court. In this essay I will review the Court’s pre-Muršić case law on minimum personal space and draw attention to the inconsistencies, then I summarize the findings of Muršić.
Blogsite of the Institute for Legal Studies
The United States has been a champion of free trade and economic globalization for many years. It was one of the architects of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade and a founding member of the World Trade Organization. However, the election of Donald Trump as the 45th President of the United States has the potential to dramatically change this picture. The new president has repeatedly blamed the current international trade arrangements for destroying jobs in the American industry sector. He promised to redesign the existing trade bargains. But are those plans realistic? How will such moves change the international trade landscape?
- Migration and the rise of populism: changes in the migration policy of Germany and Italy
- Some Thoughts About National Restrictions on Free Movement Between Member States During the COVID-19 Pandemic
- Hate Speech in Political Communication
- Hate Crimes in Hungary During the Coronavirus Outbreak
- The Responsibility to Protect Principle and State Negligence in Disease Prevention of International Concern
- Remarks on the effects of the coronavirus pandemic on the Hungarian contract law
- The Covid-19 Pandemic and International Trade
- Public Money in Political Campaigns. An Analysis on Hungarian State Propaganda